How to compare home insurance coverage side by side

Woman studying on computer
How to Compare Home Insurance Coverage Side by Side

To compare home insurance coverage side by side, you need:

  1. The Coverage Limits
  2. The Special Sub-Limits
  3. The Exclusions
  4. Special Deductibles
  5. The Price

Home insurance policies are dense, often with over 50 pages of legal language. Here are the most important coverage types you should be comparing in a home insurance quote: 

Home insurance quotes comparison grid

The Coverage

The largest coverage lines you want to check are:

  1. Your house - Coverage A - Building
    This is the coverage to replace your home if it were to be totally destroyed. It is NOT the market value of your home, but the cost to rebuild it from the ground up. 
  2. Your belongings - Coverage C - Personal Property 
    All your worldly possessions: clothes, furniture, fridge, TV, rugs, artwork, etc. There are special sublimits in Coverage C to pay attention to for categories like jewelry, computers, and bicycles. (see below)
  3. Your liability - Coverage E - Liability
    In America, we take pride in the right to sue anyone for anything. Josh may be your best friend today, but see what happens when he slips on the ice in your driveway and can't walk for 3 months. Hopefully you are never on the receiving end of a lawsuit, but just in case, make sure you have liability coverage to protect your entire net worth. If you have more than $500,000 in net worth, also buy an umbrella policy - incredibly affordable for the extra layer of protection it provides. 

The Special Sub-Limits

Each policy has about 10-20 special item categories in Coverage C that are only covered up to a specific limit. A standard homeowners insurance policy has limits on the following categories:

Home insurance category sublimits

If you have high value items in any of these categories, you should consider adding an endorsement to your policy that increases your coverage limit. For a high value item, like an engagement ring, you can also schedule an individual item

The Exclusions

There are many exclusions on a home insurance policy. Some exclusions can't be added and are never really covered:

Home insurance coverage exclusions

There are also some exclusions that CAN be purchased as add-ons to your policy:

Home insurance optional add-ons

  1. Flooding - Flood insurance always needs to be purchased as a separate policy. About 80% of flood claims from FEMA happen in a high risk flood zone and 20% of flood claims come from a medium/low risk flood zone. Check your own flood zone risk in my free risk report. If you need flood insurance, make sure you also evaluate private flood insurance. Cost can vary widely based on your flood risk zone. 
  2. Sewer Back-Up/Sump Pump or Water Backup - A common gotcha in a home insurance policy. If the water backs up in the sink or toilet and overflows, damaging your property, you are out of luck... unless you buy this optional add-on. Expect it to cost ~$10/mo extra for $10,000 in coverage.
  3. Lateral Lines Coverage or Service Line Coverage - This covers the service lines between the street and your home. Let's say a tree root grows through sewer line located on the property. You have to dig up the line and replace it at a cost of $6,500. This add-on will cover this and it is very affordable at around $3/mo. 
  4. Mold - Usually excluded and can be purchased as an add-on, but very expensive. Mold tends to do a lot of damage if left unfound as it can get into the structure and foundation of a home. Often hard to justify this purchase, but an extra reason to check for leaks often and early! (Fun fact: some states, like NJ, require $10,000 in basic fungi, mold, rot coverage)

Special Deductibles

A deductible is what you have to pay out of pocket before the insurance company foots the bill on your coverage. What people don't know is that home insurance policies sometimes can have two or more deductibles depending on the cause of damage. The most common second deductible is the Hurricane Deductible or Wind/Hail Deductible. This is often a much higher deductible than your regular deductible and gets linked to your total building coverage. For example, 1% of Coverage A. So if your house is insured for $300,000, your Wind/Hail deductible could be $3,000. (way above the standard deductible stated on the policy)

The Price

As you can see above, there are lots of ways an insurance company can give you worse coverage to show a lower price. The real question is what is the value in what you are buying. In the words of famed investor Warren Buffet: "Price is what you pay, but value is what you get." 

Insurance is a tricky product. While it can seem easy to find a cheap price and click to buy, it is better to look under the hood and see what type of coverage you are buying. Young Alfred gives you an accurate and easy to understand side by side comparison of coverage for free

Compare Home Insurance Quotes

At your service,
Young Alfred